Market Channels in the US Electronic Security Industry
Selling to the Electronic Security Equipment market
is done in a number of ways
-
through wholesale distributors
-
direct to alarm dealers
-
direct to end users
-
through OEM arrangements with other suppliers
When the industry was less mature, picking a
channel was a much more difficult decision than it
is today. Up until the early 1990's, the choice was
fairly irrevocable and determined what kind of
dealers would handle your equipment. Larger dealers
who bought direct from manufacturers would not use
equipment that was available in distribution. This
was based on the usually misguided belief that it
was important to have some kind of exclusivity of
product.
Today, many dealers have demonstrated this to be
false and in particular, the largest, national
companies have not hesitated to use the same
equipment that is available in distribution. The
fact that they will typically buy it for around 50%
of what the smaller dealer pays is seen as a
sufficient advantage. Here is our brief overview of
the channels available.
Wholesale Distribution
Wholesale distribution offers many advantages to
the new entrant to the US security market and has
been the chosen method for the vast majority of
entrants, whether domestic or foreign.
It used to be the case that more complex products
were not sold through distributors. However,
certain distributors are developing the capability
to support dealers who use relatively complex
products. This is most noticeably the case in Fire
products, where the regulatory problems mean that
the small dealer inevitably needs help. It is now
becoming the case in Access Control and CCTV. In
time, it will come in Intrusion products.
There are a number of significant downsides to
selling through distribution in the USA:
Distributors, whatever they say, do not make
significant and continuous efforts to promote any
one product. If they promote at all, it is on the
basis of a quid pro quo, and they will do the same
for a competitive product when it comes along.
Companies who sell through distribution have to
advertise and promote their product, since all
their competitors do so, and the distributor does
not. This involves attending major national and
regional trade showsas well as advertising in a
large number of security industry magazines. This
is a significant expense.
The choice of distributor is a relatively stark
one. Either ADI, the dominant player, or one of the
much smaller companies, or all of them. Most
manufacturers do not try to get the possible
benefit of giving a single distributor an
exclusive. This is because an exclusive is of no
value unless the product has some unique appeal.
Selling Direct to Installing Companies
Selling direct to installers is the natural choice
for more complex products that require a large
amount of sales effort and support. By selling
direct, the company has the option, though not the
necessity, to control access to the product to only
authorized or qualified dealers.
This could be a key part of the product strategy.
The most important aspect of this is preventing
smaller dealers from bidding on specification jobs
that have been created by an authorized dealer.
This is done either by not selling at all to such
dealers, or by selling at loaded prices to prevent
their competing on price with the authorized
dealer.
In addition, the company is not forced to undertake
an expensive, nationwide advertising campaign, nor
to go to trade shows, to be on a par with the other
products in distribution and to underpin the
distributors sales efforts.
The most significant downside to selling direct is
the need for a high level of sales effort, which
has to be addressed individually to the target
dealer. With the size of the USA, this either
limits the territory that can be served or
increases the sales costs significantly.
Selling Direct to End Users
This is an expensive option, with a very long lead
time for sales. It is undertaken usually when it is
the only practical means for the company to reach
its customers. It is common in Access Control in
the USA, much less so in other segments of the
industry. It appears that the propensity of end
users to want to buy direct goes in cycles. At some
times they are convinced of the benefits of working
with dealers or systems integrators, at other times
they get enamored with the potential savings from
buying direct.
How to choose
The single most common question that new clients
want me to help them with, is making the choice of
channel. In fact, the only ones who don't ask this
early on, have already made an assumption about
which one they will choose. Often, they have
reached a conclusion too quickly.
Look at the competition
I believe that the place to start is similar to the
decision about entering the market in the first
place. If your product is to succeed, it must
displace another product for at least some
customers. You have to identify the product(s) that
yours will displace (right down to model number)
and the reasons why the customers will switch. Ask
yourself if there is a reason why they will buy
your product differently. Nine times out of ten,
you will choose to sell the same way the competitor
does. If you think your product is the one in ten
that can be sold a different way, you may be right,
but you have added another challenge to the already
serious problem of displacing the competing
product.
No competition?
If your product is so different that you have no
existing competition, then the choice of channel is
a bit easier. For low unit cost products (sub $1000
per purchase), it is hard to beat wholesale
distributors as a way to get started. As mentioned
above, it is possible to go on to sell direct
later. An added advantage of this approach is the
very serious evaluation your product will get from
the product specialists at the distributor. They
are very reluctant to give shelf space and catalog
space to something that they don't think will sell.
For higher value products, you must do a careful
assessment of the decision making process that
leads to the purchase decisison. The decision maker
may be the dealer, systems integrator, consultant,
security director, IT manager or a committee. For
each, a slightly different marketing mix is
necessary, including the choice of distribution
channel.
|